Welcome to Into the Mystic – a gorgeous villa, available for rent, overlooking St. John’s Coral Bay, St. John, US Virgin Islands. Featured on HGTV’s show “House Hunters International”!

  • Image
  • Image 1
  • ebb5cd4c097fea127030368825c51e4c
  • banner2
  • banner3
  • banner4
  • banner5
  • banner6
  • banner7
  • banner8
  • banner9
  • banner1

Inquire/Email

  • 1 Master Bedroom / 1.5 Bath
  • Max Occupancy: 2
  • Views of Coral Bay
  • $300 Damage Deposit
  • 1 Queen size Bed
  • Non Smoking
  • Washer & Dryer
  • 960 Sq. Ft Interior
  • 1400 Sq. Ft Exterior
  • Located in Coral Bay, St. John, USVI
  • Outdoor Shower
  • 10 minutes to nearest Beach
  • Saline Outdoor Pool
  • Hot Tub
  • Full Gourmet Kitchen
  • High-Def satellite TVs, DVD,
    & Highspeed Wireless Internet
  • Central AC in whole villa
    Visa & Master Card – Accepted

Testimonial

May 30, 2016

Into the Mystic has been the most perfect place to spend our honeymoon! The views are amazing- breathtaking! Thank you for your hospitality and all of your great recommendations! We will certainly be returning for another magical vacation. All the best,
Jacob and Ashlee
Dallas, TX

May 21, 2016

Sharon,
We can only say that Into the Mystic is truly a piece of heaven on earth. We celebrated out 25th wedding anniversary here and have never had a trip be so relaxing and peaceful. The house is so well stocked that we didn’t have to worry about a thing. We will always keep our memories tucked away in our hearts. Anyone who came before us or comes after us know that you are blessed to have this experience.
Brian and Dianea
Graniteville, SC

May 13, 2016

Dear Sharon,
We truly felt we were in paradise in your villa and we came to St. John to celebrate our 40th anniversary and we were filled with love, joy, adventure and tranquility at “Into the Mystic” and the island. We had celebrated out honeymoon 40 years ago in St. Thomas and spent one day on St. John. We feel blessed that we stayed here at this amazing villa with such a gorgeous view! Thanks for the memories! God Bless!
Chris and Steve, Tallmadge, Ohio

April 24, 2016

This has been such a memorable trip! The view from the house is breath taking! There is nothing like it! Thank you for a wonderful honeymoon Sharon. St. John is filled with so many kind people, that made our trip even more enjoyable. We hope to return in the future! We are so blessed!
Logan and Morgan
Springfield, Ohio

April 9, 2016

Surely this is a little bit of paradise! Where else can you sit a top a beautiful mountain with such a tranquil majestic view…not to mention the gorgeous villa with pool, hot tub and everything anyone could want. As we prepare to leave we are already planning a time to return! Thank you Sharon for being s gracious host and providing us with rest, rejuvenation and amazing memories.
Dan and Jennifer, Elizabethtown, PA

March 19, 2016

Thank you for sharing your lovely villa with us. This was our fourth time to St. John and your villa ranks #1 on our list. The view from the hot tub can’t be beat and was enjoyed daily. The house was well appointed and basic necessities were ample.
The island is its usual amazing place.
Deb and Stuart, Cape Elizabeth, ME

March 12, 2016

Dear Sharon,
Your villa is as beautiful as your island and we are so grateful that you shared it with us. The outdoor living space is amazing and the view from the hot tub is also. The beaches are beautiful and the water is beyond belief. Our favorite was the beach at Francis Bay and we highly recommend it to anyone reading this. Thank you for your hospitality.
Bob and Karen
Mileis, MA

February 1, 2016

Your home is beyond beautiful and tranquil! Im so happy I came across your villa online! Thank you for sharing a little piece of paradise! I couldn’t think of any better way to have spent our honeymoon! Coral Bay is a tropical dream and we look froward to visiting again. Everything about the home, amenities and thought that went into this home shows and it made our trip even better than either of us could have hoped for. We can’t wait to plan our next visit.
Grand Rapids. MI

January 29, 2016

We are so glad we chose to stay at Into the Mystic in Coral Bay. It allowed us unforgettable opportunities to explore beaches, hike, snorkel, and discover multiple rum drinks and gave us a home base with beautiful views including sun and moon rises. A bit of heaven on earth, thanks for sharing Sharon!
Pattie and Don
La Crosse, WI

January 4, 2016

Sharon, Thanks for being the gracious host the you are. This place is perfect in every way. Second to none. “It just doesn’t get any better than this.” We are looking forward to our next visit.
Kim and Rick

December 25, 2016

Sharon,
This was our first trip to St. John but definitely wont be our last. This was the best vacation we have ever had not just because of the beautiful beaches but mostly because of your hospitality and gorgeous villa. Some of our many highlights…Maho Bay and swimming with sea turtles, snorkeling the trail at Trunk Bay, Tuna Ponzu and conch fritters at Aqua Bistro, free rum in our smoothies, every moment spent in the villa from sunrise to sunset. On our last night here I am reminded of a quote…”She said she usually cried at least once each day not because she was sad, but because the world was so beautiful and life is so short.”
Suzy and Steve
Wilmington, NC

November 2, 2015

Dear Sharon,
Thank you so much for your generous hospitality this week. It was perfect and memorable. You’ve really thought of it all. We really would’ve only packed out swimsuit had we known how well stocked your home is! We’ll know for next time. Trust me, we haven’t even left and already we’re planning our the next trip -officially hooked on St. John. So blessed to have spent our anniversary here at your lovely home and island. Hoping for many more!
Stacie and Jason
Houma, Louisiana

August 15, 2015

We came to St. John to exchange vows and begin our marriage- we came to St. John for adventure- we heard some visit St. John and never leave their villas- which is a shame because this island is rich with lovely people and fabulous attractions- when we weren’t sailing, snorkeling, hiking, off roading, beaching or boarding, we found refuge here which was the perfect compliment to our thirst for adventure- particularly for all things underwater, where in my opinion is where every visitor must end up at some point- its just breathtaking.
We never turned on the AC in the main house, just enough to open the screens and the trade winds and the fan will do the rest.
My favorite thing was to leave all the lights off (they attract bugs anyway) and sit outside not the porch in the pitch black-hearing the sounds- with a candle lit. Thanks Sharon for an amazing stay at “into the mystic” We plan to be back many times in the future for anniversaries. Pleasure meeting you Sharon, all the best!
Dereck and Erin
Philadelphia, PA

July 14, 2015

Sharon,
You’re place is truly amazing! From the decor to the view you have done it right. My husband and I came for our honeymoon and for those short six days time seemed to stop! Thank you for all your recommendations form Miss Vie’s to hiking Rams Head and visiting/snorkeling all the beaches. This trip is definitely our favorite. Thank you for making this, the first chapter in our married life, so perfect. We will be back for sure!
Kristen and Kyle
Austin, TX

July 4, 2015

Happy forth of July!! We came back! Our second stay here at Into the Mystic was just as wonderful as the first! We absolutely love it here, everything about this villa and the beautiful island of St. John is simply magical. We plan on coming back here plenty of times! Thank you for always making sure we have an excellent stay.
Manuel and Odaymis, FL

June 20, 2015

Sharon, Thank you so much for sharing your piece of paradise with us! We couldn’t have asked for a better backdrop for our honeymoon. The amenities at Into the Mystic along with your recommendations allowed us to enjoy every day to its fullest. Our favorites were Miss Lucys brunch, ZoZo’s, hiking to Watermelon Cay for snorkeling and little Lameshur beach. We will certainly be back some day!
Thank you,
Sean and Katie
Horsham, PA

Into the Mystic was heavenly! It was all we had dreamed it would be judging by the pictures we had seen; but actually being here , we realized that no picture can do it justice…it takes your breath away. Between the advice we received before arriving and the excellent welcome binder we had a fantastic yet unobtrusive personal guide for the week. The gays give you our seal of approval! Hope to return soon!
Thank you!!

Doug and Eric NY, NY

Your lovely villa felt like home to us for our one week. We cooked, read, wrote and moon watched in the hot tub, we visited 6 great snorkeling beaches and found your location perfect. We even watch our first episode of LOST. Thank you for opening up this special place so others like us can experience Coral Bay, St. John.

Phil and Suzy

By far our most memorable trip down yet! We spent two weeks…got married…saw a meteor shower…sunsets/sunrises…and just enjoyed every moment. Than you for opening your home to us.

Kat and Casey

Our first trip to St. John was more special and amazing than we thought, especially because of Into the Mystic! From the moment we arrived, we realized your beautiful, first class home was the perfect start and finish to each day. Not only is the villa breathtaking in design, location and décor, but it has a comfortable and relaxing feel to it! With the gorgeous view from every angle to the lovely landscaping and amenities, we didn’t find anything missing – even all the beach chairs, snorkel equipment… We enjoyed Coral Bay and Cruz Bay so much that we look forward to a return trip real soon. Thank you for allowing us to experience and enjoy St. John while staying at Into the Mystic!

Greg and Eileen Long Island, NY

To “Into the Mystic”,
Thanks for the peaceful, beautiful times we enjoyed this week! It was truly a spectacular time. Garry and I hope to return with friends and family some day. Your place is absolutely charming. Save us a place in the future, we’ll be back again.
Thanks so much!

Gary and Katherine Athens, Alabama

The villa was fantastic, you have thought of everything (beach chairs, snorkel gear, etc), we really enjoyed it. This is the 5th time we have here, but by far the best villa we have stayed in. Waterlemon Cay was the best snorkeling in St. John –well worth the hike there. Had a wonderful time, thanks for sharing your home.

Carrie and Bob Fountain Hills, AZ

Thank you so much for sharing your villa. We came to St. John for our honeymoon and we couldn’t have asked for a better place to stay. This is our first time visiting St. John and we had such a wonderful time! Thanks again!

Katie and Nathan Baton Rouge, LA

Dear Sharon

We stayed in your villa July 7th through the 14th as a celebration of our 15th anniversary. Just want to let you know how much we loved the house. You have really thought of every possible thing someone would enjoy while on vacation and we felt very much “at home”. The location is perfect, the landscaping is so beautiful, everything is just so comfortable and relaxing. Can’t wait to return!

6/21/14

Dear Sharon
The hospitality shown to my husband and I during our stay was well received. We spent our honeymoon on the island 20 yrs ago and returned to celebrate our anniversary. The villa and vistas were more spectacular than we remembered. Your recommendations for hiking, snorkeling and dining were spot on. We mixed some relaxing and exploring while we were on the island. The memories we have made here will hopefully hold us over till our next visit.
Thank you
Greg and Pam
Orlando, FL

6/28/14

Sharon
The villa was amazing –the views were incredible- we loved Trunk bay @ night –Aqua Bistro was a favorite as well as Island Blues. Thanks for everything you do to make sure your guests have the perfect experience! Happy 4th of July!
Bethani and Adam
Pittsburgh, PA

7/9/14

Sharon
We had such a wonderful time! I can’t think of a better way to spend our 10 yr anniversary. We appreciate all the time and effort and advice to help make our trip even that more special. This really is an amazing place! We will be looking forward to coming back in the future!
Jason and Brooke
Bandera, TX

6/11/14

Dear Sharon
Your beautiful villa was everything we had hoped for and more- Escape from worlds worries and a peaceful paradise where we could “recharge” The stunning views were complimented by the outstanding amenities here. It is clear that you take pride in offering the best possible experience and we truly appreciate that. Writing this as we are about to leave it is hard to go, but we will certainly carry with us the great memories and hope to return once again
Thank you again!
Laura and Jonathan
Greene, NYC

7/15/14

Sharon
We had an absolutely amazing week here! It was a perfect way to celebrate our 10th anniversary. We were able to enjoy everything St. John has to offer during the day (thanks for the recommendations) and still look forward to everything our villa had to offer at night. The pool the hot tub and the views were superb! We will remember this week always
Colleen and Mike
St. Louis, MO

7/26/14

Sharon
Super Awesome, fun amazing place for our first anniversary! You do it right. Thanks for all of your suggestions and help. This place is magical!
Stef and Josh
Nashville, music city USA

8/6/14

My husband surprised me by not showing me any pictures of your place- wow was I blown away! What a beautiful place with everything I could ever want! We honeymooned on St. Thomas and came to St. John several days . I have loved every minute of our return here for our 25th anniversary! We have loved exploring all the beaches and then coming back here to relax in the pool , hot tub and star gaze. Best of all –what an amazing place to reconnect with my best friend. Thank you.
I also enjoyed the book “between the sheets” and a great day on Bad Kitty
Thanks for sharing your place and all your recommendations!! I will spread the word of your amazing place.
Debbie and Dave
Dublin, OH

8/12/14

Sharon,
We truly enjoyed celebrating our honeymoon in St. John at your villa. Beyond your beautiful home we loved visiting a different bay everyday to find the most amazing snorkeling ever! Our favorite was a toss up between Haulover and Salt Pond. The Rams Head hike might tip the scales. The Ahi Ponzu on Friday night at Aqua Bistro was our favorite dinner an an epic breakfast at Chateaux Bordeax provided Mango/Pinn stuffed french toast and views that took our breath away. We stumbled upon a couple of Gems in Cruz Bay -Joes BBQ and Castaways happy hour/bingo. If you don’t mind fried local fare Miss Vie’s is a must try-conch fritters and johnny cakes. Quick lunch at Pickles hit the spot. All day sail on Sail Pepper was a blast with Kim and Lance. She makes a delicious pain killer. We look forward to our next visit and trying more of what we missed like North Shore beaches and a trip to the Baths. We will definitely be back!
Blessed beyond out dreams,
Steve and Nicole
Santa Barbara, CA

10/4/14

Sharon,
We are now spoiled for tropical vacations. We have spent our time here trying to figure out how we will ever top our week at Into the Mystic. First, the view is incredible and always different at different times of the day. Second, you have thought of everything. The house has everything we needed. Third, the island was perfect for a laid back, relaxing 10th Anniversary. Thank you for sharing this beautiful house and place with us.

Dan And Cheryl
Richmond, VA

10/19/14

Sharon,
I can’t even begin to explain how awesome out stay her was! Kurt and I made many memories here that we will remember a lifetime. We will definitely be back! We appreciate ALL you did to help us! I can’t say enought about “Into the Mystic”. Best Wishes to you always and May God bless you.
Kurt and Shana

10/27/14

Sharon,
Thank you so much for supplying us with the perfect venue for our honeymoon! It provided us with the ideal combination of relaxation and activity. From having little Lameshur beach to ourselves, to parasailing, partaking in a sunset sail, or just enjoying the Coral Bay view-we truly enjoyed it all. Thank you for being an excellent hostess. We will hope to be back to the island someday soon!
Thanks Again!
Joe & Lauren
Minneapolis, MN

11/8/14

We had an absolute wonderful time! The villa was a perfect place to unwind each evening! We enjoyed so much of St. John and look forward to coming back. Aqua Bistro is great! Snorkeling on Jimmy’s boat was amazing and still -trunk bay is our favorite (the sand and always blue water). Thank you Sharon for sharing a piece of your oasis.
Mike and Jaclyn
Chicago, IL

11/16/14

This was a wonderful place to spend our honeymoon! We got to explore many of St. John’s amazing beaches (Ive never seen water that blue in my life!) and relax in the villa. We loved the view from relaxing in the hot tub! We look forward to coming back to the Virgin Islands for an anniversary in the future. Thank you Sharon for everything! Our week was beautiful.
Ali and Chris
Baton Rouge, LA

11/29/14

Thank you for such an amazing villa! We absolutely love it here and can’t wait to come back next year. Wouldn’t even think of staying anywhere else.
Judy and Craig

12/6/14

We have been to many islands and have now found our “home”. Both St. John and Into the Mystic. We followed all of your recommendations and all were fabulous. Your exceptional attention to detail makes this already beautiful villa amazing. We will be back next year!
Darrah and Buddy
Jonesville, LA